Rebuttal to "on the Unforgeability of 'Privacy-Preserving Aggregation-Authentication Scheme for Safety Warning System in Fog-Cloud Based VANET"'

Lin recently claimed that the privacy-preserving aggregation authentication scheme (PPAAS) based on a certificateless aggregation signcryption scheme (CASS) proposed in our paper (IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security, vol.17, pp.317-331, Jan.2022) suffers from a forgery attack from type II adversary. In this paper, we show that this attack is not valid since the adversary outputs a trivial forged ciphertext. Specifically, the adversary has the master secret key and randomly selects the secret values of all users.