Tunneling criteria and a nonadiabatic term for strong-field ionization

We investigate tunneling ionization of a model helium atom in a strong circularly polarized short laser pulse using the classical backpropagation method and compare ten different tunneling criteria on the same footing, aiming for a consistent classical picture of the tunneling dynamics. These tunneling criteria are categorized into velocity-based, position-based, and energy-based criteria according to different notions of a tunnel exit. We find that velocity-based criteria give consistent tunneling exit characteristics with nonadiabatic effects fully included. Other criteria are either inconsistent or only able to include nonadiabatic effects partially. Furthermore, we construct a simple tunneling rate formula, identify a term in the rate responsible for the nonadiabatic effects, and demonstrate the importance of this term.